data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/21238/21238646c31d9d7778fa67d51238a1dfc9f5bf9d" alt=""
@Eruca:
To me, Gene Wilder's version was eccentric and a touch crazy. He was cooped up in his factory for so long, you're bound to be a bit strange. He was strange in a funny way. Like...when the kids got into the predicaments he acted like he didn't care because he was weeding out the bad eggs and looking for a child that had his same sort of whimsy.
Johnny Depp's depiction of Willy Wonka, was cast in a more...childish light. Since basically his father left him because he wanted to eat candy. He had Michael Jackson type syndrome where he wanted to have fun and be child-like, and for and adult that's just creepy. He seemed like the kind of guy that would 'kidnap' children and play with them. Maybe not in a "bad touch" way, but it just didn't come across as someone who should be around kids.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/63232/6323247c1b4bf3dac8924a8b7cdb165ac20f0be4" alt=""